قاعدة بيانات السوابق القضائية

الاتجار بالأشخاص

Mother Doe I v. Sheikh Hamdan Bin Rashid al Maktoum

موجز لوقائع القضية

The plaintiffs were former child camel jockeys and their parents. Plaintiffs sued the defendants under the Alien Tort Statute (28 USC 1350), claiming that the defendants had engaged in and conspired to engage in slave trade and in forced child labour in violation of the law of nations. Plaintiffs also brought state law claims of battery, assault, intentional and/or negligent infliction of emotional distress, wrongful death, and survival claims against the defendants. The suit was brought in the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Kentucky.

This class action arose from the trafficking of young boys from Africa and South Asia, aged 2-12 (approximately), to work in the camel racing industry in the United Arab Emirates and other Arab states. According to the complaint, young boys were abducted and/or sold and enslaved in camel training camps to work as trainers and jockeys under the supervision of overseers. The children were reportedly starved, beaten, sexually abused and forced to work under harsh and oppressive conditions. When the children reached their teen years, and became too big to ride as jockeys, they were abandoned (e.g. sent back to their homeland) without any education, resources or assistance.

Ultimately, the federal District Court for the Eastern District of Kentucky dismissed this case for lack of personal jurisdiction over the named defendant.

الكاتب:
Human Trafficking Database of the University of Michigan Law School

الكلمات الرئيسية

بروتوكول الإتجار بالبشر:
مادة3، بروتوكول الإتجار بالبشر
مادة5، بروتوكول الإتجار بالبشر
أفعال:
تجنيد
وسائل النقل
تحويل
الإيواء
استلام
وسائل:
التهديد أو استخدام القوة أوغيرها من أشكال الإجبار
الأختطاف
خداع/غش
إساءة استخدام السلطة أو موقف الضعف
الغرض من الإستغلال:
العمل أو الخدمة بالإجبار
شكل الإتجار:
عبر الحدود الوطنية
القطاع الذى حدث به الإستغلال:
قطاعات اخرى

المعلومات الإجرائية

النظام القانوني:
القانون الأنغلوسكسوني
الحكم القضائي الأخير:
المحكمة الابتدائية
نوع الإجراءات:
مدني
المتهمون حوكموا:
معا (محاكمة واحدة)
 

1st Instance: 

Court: U.S. District Court of Eastern District of Kentucky
Location: Kentucky
Date of decision:  November 18, 2008
Reference: Mother Doe I v. Al Maktoum, 2008 WL 4965169 (2008) 

Other clarifying information: This case was first brought in the Southern District of Florida, but dismissed for lack of personal jurisdiction over the defendants.  See Mother Doe I v. Al Maktoum, 632 F.Supp.2d 1130 (Fl. Dist. Ct. 2007)

 
 

الضحايا / المدَّعون في المحكمة الابتدائية

المدعي:
Mother Doe I
نوع الجنس:
أنثى

Suing on behalf of a class of young boys.

الضحية:
Anonymous individuals
نوع الجنس:
الطفل

The defendants were accused of trafficking over 10,000 children, between 2 and 12 years of age, for their exploitation as camel jockeys.

المدعى عليهم / المتهمون في المحكمة الابتدائية

عدد المتهمين الآخرين:
500
المدعى عليه:
Sheikh Hamdan Bin Rashid Al Maktoum
نوع الجنس:
ذكر
الجنسية:
إماراتي
الاستدلال القانوني:

The District Court dismissed all claims against the defendant for lack of personal jurisdiction.  Neither the federal nor the state law provided sufficient basis for the plaintiffs to sue the defendants in Kentucky. 

المدعى عليه:
Sheikh Mohammad bin Rashed al-Maktoum
نوع الجنس:
ذكر
الجنسية:
إماراتي

الاتهامات/الادعاءات/القرارات

المدعى عليه:
Sheikh Hamdan Bin Rashid Al Maktoum
تفاصيل التهم:
Engaging in Slavery/Slave Trade in Violation of the Law of Nations
تفاصيل التهم:
Conspiracy to Engage in, Aiding and Abetting, Intentionally Facilitating and/or Recklessly Disregarding Slavery/Slave Trade in Violation of the Law of Nations
تفاصيل التهم:
Primarily Engaging in, or Aiding and Abetting, Intentionally Facilitating and/or Recklessly Disregarding Forced Child Labour in Violation of the Law of Nations
تفاصيل التهم:
Battery, Assault, Intentional Infliction of Emotional Distress
المدعى عليه:
Sheikh Mohammad bin Rashed al-Maktoum
تفاصيل التهم:
Engaging in Slavery/Slave Trade in Violation of the Law of Nations
تفاصيل التهم:
Conspiracy to Engage in, Aiding and Abetting, Intentionally Facilitating and/or Recklessly Disregarding Slavery/Slave Trade in Violation of the Law of Nations
تفاصيل التهم:
Primarily Engaging in, or Aiding and Abetting, Intentionally Facilitating and/or Recklessly Disregarding Forced Child Labor in Violation of the Law of Nations
تفاصيل التهم:
Battery, Assault, Intentional Infliction of Emotional Distress

المحكمة

United States District Court for the Eastern District of Kentucky

المصادر / الاقتباسات

http://www.law.umich.edu/CLINICAL/HUTRAFFICCASES/Pages/CaseDisp.aspx?caseID=453

المرفقات